"Even small changes in the abundance or location of clouds could change the climate more than the anticipated changes caused by greenhouse gases..."



— Dave Dahl

First I should tell you how I came by this information. As a technical content producer, research is the biggest part of my job, and as a skeptic, I avoid anecdotes, observations without verifiable data, and most witness testimony.

So when I looked into persistent contrail clouds, I began with secondary research from credible sources such as NASA, NOAA and so on. After that, I spoke with scientist friends, teachers, weather modification pilots, meteorologists and climatologists.

Then I called the Science Director at NASA. He answered.

He directed most of my questions to a cloud-aerosol interaction specialist there who filled me in on some of NASA's atmospheric research and satellite instruments.

I studied the clouds in Europe, Asia and Micronesia as well as the east and west coasts of the US, hired helicopters to determine exact altitudes of clouds and took time-lapse videos of natural and artificial clouds forming.

But what I found in the US Library of Congress in the first couple weeks is what intrigued me enough to continue: the beginning of our concerns about human activity directly affecting the climate.

In the 1960s, the Department of Transportation noticed that jet aircraft, which by then had quickly become a widely popular mode of transport, were affecting the weather.

They realized that jet airplanes were creating clouds in such abundance that the consistent change in cloud cover would have greater climate implications. They called it "inadvertent climate variation."

It was no longer an obscure, remote theory. They were witnessing it.

In a 1974 report to the US President and Congress, the US Department of Transportation wrote that "inadvertent climate variation is of worldwide concern."

That year an enormous study of the atmosphere called GARP was launched. It involved 70 countries, 40 vessels and 13 aircraft as well as satellites, buoys and land stations.

Following the GARP study, in 1978, Congress declared climate variation an issue of National Security.

This origin story corresponded with NASA's primer Understanding the Importance of Clouds, which states on the first page that "even small changes in the abundance or location of clouds could change the climate more than the anticipated changes caused by greenhouse gases."

So it followed to ask, How can we alter the abundance and location of clouds? And it turns out, we are; human-caused cloud cover is in fact significant, and is a major factor in anthropogenic climate alteration- maybe even the primary factor.

To begin with, jet aircraft are not only the biggest machines humans produce on a large scale, they're also the only machines that actually inject CO2 directly into the upper atmosphere.

But there's a lot more to the story of how aircraft affect the climate.

We talk about CO2, but we rarely discuss its counterpart, H2O. When we burn fuel- hydrocarbons - there are two main resulting byproducts: CO2 and H2O. For every gallon of jet fuel used, a gallon of water is created as a byproduct, in the form of invisible vapor.

Read the full article  

1. Aircraft produce about 10 trillion cubic feet of water vapor annually.

It's true that jet airplanes are larger, have more powerful engines and fly more frequently than ever... about 700 million passenger flights per year in the US alone.

For each gallon of jet fuel burned, aircraft produce a gallon of water, because H2O is one of the two chemical byproducts resulting from the combustion of hydrocarbons. Current jet fuel use is about 60 billion gallons per year, so that's also about 60 billion gallons of water being manufactured in the atmoshphere annually, or nearly half a trillion pounds of H2O ... frozen water vapor that doesn't just fall back down to Earth.

In the low air pressure, sub-zero temperatures where contrails form, steam from the exhaust freezes immediately and expands to a much greater area than its sea-level volume. Since the steam is gaseous and warmer than the environment around it, it continues to rise rather than fall. 60 billion gallons of fuel = 60 billion gallons of water = approximately 10 to 20 trillion cubic feet of ice crystal clouds added to the atmosphere every year, most of which is injected into the northern hemisphere of the planet.

But there's more to artificial clouds than just frozen H2O.

2. Weather modification programs affect contrail cloud formation.

Weather modification means cloud seeding with silver iodide (AgI)— hygroscopic metallic aerosols that provide a dense field of cloud condensation nuclei (CCNs) to thicken clouds and induce precipitation. Condensation nuclei are the basis of cloud development. When mixed with moisture, silver iodide promotes cloud formation by providing CCNs that jet exhaust moisture can bond with. The invisible cloud-seeding chemicals are dispersed in the atmosphere at around 20,000 feet, in front of incoming moisture fronts, enhancing contrails from jet air traffic and often spawning cloud cover prior to the storm's arrival.

Silver iodide aerosols are invisible once dispersed, and the contrails from the planes burning the flares are minimal and usually disappear because these are small jets that are already at their cruising altitude; that is, using relatively little fuel. However, when large aircraft ascend through the seeded fields of silver iodide at these higher altitudes, their contrails become instantly visible. The extreme photosensitivity of the crystalline-shaped silver iodide aerosols combine with the highly-reflective ice crystals from the exhaust to form bright white contrail wakes behind the plane that tend to persist rather than disperse.

3. Weather modification programs burn silver iodide flares to induce precipitation.

Weather modification companies use fleets of jets and high-altitude propeller planes that have flares fixed to the wings of the aircraft. When the flares burn, they release silver iodide, a salt-based chemical (potassium iodide and silver nitrate), which provides abundant cloud condensation nuclei to spawn and thicken clouds.

Cloud seeders ignite as many flares as possible before incoming storms in order to maximize precipitation. There are other less common applications for cloud seeding, such as breaking up hailstorms with surfactants in order to reduce damage, but precipitation enhancement is the primary reason for weather modification.

4. Local governments hire the cloud seeding companies.

In the United States, county governments are typically the ones who hire weather modification companies to seed clouds. The programs are designed to enhance precipitation and increase water supplies. These ongoing precipitation enhancement projects are typically paid for by consumers through a Public Purpose Program surcharge on their utility bills.

Local governments see cloud seeding as a good value for obtaining additional water; other sources are more costly, if any are even available.

Some states have had legal disputes about cloud seeding, including New York, Oklahoma, Washington, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, Montana, South Dakota, North Dakota, Texas and California.

Dry states in the US like California have seeded the atmosphere with silver iodide every year since the 1960s. Other states have caught on and, as the worldwide water shortage begins to affect more and more cities, the weather modification industry has expanded drastically over the past few decades.

Counties in these U.S. states have conducted and/or still conduct extended cloud-seeding programs:

Most other states have also experimented with weather modification. (For more, just Google "precipitation enhancement" or "cloud seeding" plus your state.)

5. Countries worldwide use cloud seeding regularly.

As global water supplies diminish, few alternatives exist to provide enough water for growing populations and increasing agricultural needs. Just as most western states in the US conduct ongoing cloud seeding programs for precipitation enhancement, almost any country you can name uses cloud seeding to increase rainfall and snowpack that keeps rivers flowing through the summer, including Europe, South America, the Middle East, Asia and even Australia. China seeds the clouds in over 2,000 counties.

The massive amounts of cloud condensation nuclei result in thicker, more persistent contrails, more artificial clouds and hazy skies over Earth's northern hemisphere.

Cloud seeding with AgI began in the 1960s; "climate variation" concerns started in the 1970s.

6. Artificial clouds cool AND warm the Earth.

Like natural clouds, artificial clouds can drastically affect the weather: In the daytime they block the sun, creating shade and reflecting some solar radiation back into space. But at night, clouds have a blanketing effect that keeps warm air trapped.

The coldest nights are usually cloudless ones since the heat can escape from the Earth. Clouds also absorb and re-emit heat, so cloud cover makes it even warmer at night. Warmer air also means higher pressure, and high pressures can also help repel some storms, preventing rain.

7. Artificial clouds can intensify storms.

When a moisture front presents itself, cloud seeding companies go into action, dispersing silver iodide in front of the incoming storm... specifically, over areas of land where precipitation is desired. These hygroscopic aerosols provide a field of CCNs for jet exhaust moisture to bond with and, combined with the higher ice crystal saturation that comes from moisture preceding the storm, aircraft can spawn thick clouds before the storm clouds arrive.

This creates a shady area in the path of the incoming front, providing a low-pressure "downhill run" for the storm. In fact, this can allow some precipitation to arrive that would otherwise be repelled by higher pressure.

Visible contrail clouds begin to form when jets reach a high enough altitude— around 25,000 feet— and tend to stop when the plane reaches its cruising altitude, where the ice crystal saturation is lower and the jet is using less fuel.

8. In the US, artificial clouds tend to move eastward.

In the United States, weather typically moves across the country from left to right with the jet stream. This means storms we intensify in the western states tend to flow toward the eastern states. Through precipitation enhancement programs, we thicken and accelerate storms, which continue eastward with the winds... along with the extra cloud condensation nuclei we introduce into the atmosphere to enhance precipitation.

How often do the western states seed the clouds? Every time there's potential for rain or snow. We need the water. But who is aware of the downstream consequences?

9. Artificial clouds destroy the ozone layer.

Recently scientists found that stratospheric water vapor destroys ozone. This is troubling because in addition to adding CO2 directly into the upper atmosphere, jet aircraft inject their water vapor into the lower stratosphere where the ozone layer helps protect the Earth from solar radiation.

NASA researchers also found that high-altitude clouds are formed around condensation nuclei comprised of "metallic aerosols and mineral dust"-- the ingredients that are in cloud-seeding flares.

In addition, our heavy cloud seeding practices using salt-based material may temporarily inhibit evaporation in some areas by increasing the surface salinity of water bodies that provide the humidity for cloud formation.

10. Cloud seeding flares contain toxic metallic aerosols.

Just like road flares, which also contain toxic metals, cloud seeding flares have to burn in wet, high-wind conditions.

Besides silver nitrate and potassium iodide (an inorganic salt chemical) cloud seeding flares contain incendiary chemicals and metals that are toxic to living things, including aluminum, strontium and magnesium.

As the big commercial (and military) jet aircraft ascend through areas of high relative humidity (ice crystal saturation) or dense cloud condensation nuclei, exhaust moisture bonds with the nuclei to form ice crystals. Like natural clouds, depending on where the sun is, contrail clouds can appear bright white, dark gray, or colorful.

Artificial clouds change the Earth's weather.

"Climate" = weather over time.

The Vonnegut Climate Change Theory

Named after Dr. Bernard Vonnegut, the Vonnegut Theory states that aircraft are the primary cause of human-accelerated climate change, through the frozen H2O and CO2 produced by jet airplane traffic which continues to collect and build up in the upper atmosphere.

The Vonnegut Climate Change Theory holds that:

  1. Human activity has accelerated the warming phase of Earth's 100,000-year glacial-interglacial climate cycle.

  2. Humans are significantly and constantly altering the abundance and location of clouds (atmospheric H2O), which directly affects Earth's weather.

  3. Changing the weather constantly also changes the climate; the "climate" is the weather over time.

  4. Because jet engines produce a gallon of water for every gallon of fuel burned (in the form of frozen H20 gas), a significant amount of high-altitude cloud cover is created by jet aircraft traffic. Artificial clouds spawned by aircraft directly affect winds, air pressures and temperatures.

  5. Because the H2O gas produced by aircraft is initially hot, the frozen vapor does not "fall" back down; it continues to rise and collects in the sub-freezing, low-pressure, low-gravity environment.

  6. The trillions of cubic feet of frozen water vapor created by jet aircraft every year (mostly in the northern hemisphere) is in the form of expanding gaseous clouds of microcrystals which continue to rise from the lower stratosphere, collecting and building up in the mesosphere.

  7. Even though it is usually invisible, H2O buildup in the atmosphere has an insulative effect which, along with the CO2, reduces the amount of thermal energy radiating away from the Earth.

  8. Weather modification activity around the world promotes persistent contrail cloud formation through frequent silver iodide and CO2 dispersal for precipitation enhancement; denser levels of condensation nuclei are now are a constant part of Earth's atmosphere.

  9. Storms in the western United States that are enhanced by cloud seeding (i.e., in all the western states in America), combined with accelerated wind caused by artificial clouds preceding the storms, may create downwind super-storms and flooding in the eastern states.

  10. In addition to affecting cloud production, the continuous global dispersal of silver iodide (which uses flares that distribute toxic metallic chemicals into the atmosphere), may have other large-scale unintentional consequences for Planet Earth, including drastically affecting soil pH, ground evaporation, plant growth, insects and microbes.


  1. 01: The Effects of Artificial Clouds on Climate
  2. 02: Contrails, Chemtrails and Artificial Clouds
  3. 03: NASA: The Importance of Understanding Clouds
  4. 04: Let's Stop Confusing Geoengineering with Weather Modification
  5. Active Climate Stabilization: Practical Physics-Based Approaches...
  6. Advanced Global Atmospheric Gases Experiment
  7. Aerosols: More Than Meets the Eye
  8. AMS Statement of Climate Change
  9. AMS Policy on Climate Services
  10. AMS Committee on Atmospheric Radiation
  11. An Interpretation of the Mechanisms of Ice Crystal Formation...
  12. Artificial Rain Soothes Maharashtra
  13. Artificial Snowfall from Mountain Clouds
  14. Artificial Rain Soothes Maharashtra
  15. Assembly Resolutions In Force
  16. Atmospherics, Inc.
  17. Availability of Groundwater Data for California
  18. Aviation Investment and Modernization Act of 2007
  19. Bangalore: Monsoon Plays Truant - Government Mulls Cloud Seeding
  20. Bias Corrected and Downscaled WCRP
  21. Can Simulated Volcanic Eruptions Reverse Global Warming? (Video)
  22. A Case Study of Jet Stream Clouds
  23. A Case Study of Mesoscale and Plume Dispersion
  24. Climate Response to a Geoengineered Brightening of Subtropical...
  25. Climate Stewardship and Innovation Act of 2007
  27. Cloud seeding effort adds extra pilot and new hangar
  28. Cloud seeding: taking off in West Africa
  29. CMIP3 Climate and Hydrology Projections
  30. Contrails reduce daily temperature range
  31. Convention on the Prohibition of Military or Any Other Hostile Use...
  32. Costs and benefits of geo-engineering in the Stratosphere
  33. Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP)
  34. Craghan, Michael, Physical Geography
  35. Critical Issues in Weather Modification Research
  36. Crystal Face Project
  37. Declining Snowpack in Western North America
  38. Drinking Water Treatment and Distribution
  39. Drought in the Upper Colorado River Basin
  40. Emissions of Greenhouse Gases in the United States (EPA)
  41. Environmental Impacts of Precipitation Enhancement: Results and...
  42. Federal Aviation Administration Facility Consolidation Moratorium Act of 2007
  43. Federal Aviation Research and Development Reauthorization Act of 2007
  44. Flannery, Tim, The Weather Makers
  45. Global Warming and Ice Ages
  46. Geoengineering: Destroying the Atmosphere (Video)
  47. The Geoengineering Option
  48. Geoengineering Volcanic Eruptions to Fight Climate Change (Video)
  49. History of cloud seeding
  50. Houghton , John, Global Warming: The Complete Briefing
  51. How Good Are Our Conceptual Models of Orographic Cloud Seeding?
  52. Idaho Public Utilities Commission - Case IPC-E-05
  53. Impacts of climate change and weather modification on hydrologic characteristics....
  54. Jet Engines: Fundamentals of Theory, Design and Operation
  55. Laser-induced condensation shows promise for cloud seeding
  56. A Model Based Feasibility Study of Glaciogenic Seeding...
  57. Mitigation of Hail Damages by Clouds Seeding
  58. NASA Facts about Aerosols
  59. NASA/Langley Cloud and Radiation Research
  60. NASA/Langley Minis Group's High Water Content Research
  61. National Climate Protection Act of 1978
  62. National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2012
  63. The Need for Cloud Seeding
  64. North American Weather Consultants, Inc.
  65. Observationsof Silver Iodide Plumes over the Grand Mesa
  66. Optimizing Cloud Seeding for Water and Energy in california
  67. OSHA Chemical Contaminant Levels
  68. Policy Implications of Greenhouse Warming: Mitigation...
  69. The Potential Use of Winter Cloud Seeding Programs
  70. Precipitation Enhancement
  71. Precipitation for Augmentation of Rain and Hail Suppression
  72. Quantifying Precipitation Suppression Due to Air Pollution
  73. Radiative forcing potential of different climate geoengineering options
  74. Research on global sun block needed now
  75. A Review of the Sierra Cooperative Pilot Project
  76. Report to the President and Congress, 1974
  77. Salt Nuclei, Wind and Daily Rainfall in Hawaii
  78. The Santa Barbara Cloud Seeding Project in Coastal Southern California
  79. Satellite-Based Insights into Precipitation Formation Processes...
  80. Sea change in salinity heralds shift in rainfall
  81. Separation between Cloud-Seeding and Air-Pollution Effects
  82. Silver Iodide Plume Characteristics Over the Bridger Mountain Range
  83. Silver Iodide Toxicity according to the Weather Modification Association
  84. Southern Plains Experiment in Cloud Seeding
  85. Statement of Dr. Waleed Abdalati, NASA
  86. Sulfate Aerosol and Global Warming
  87. Summary of Trace Chemicals and Physical Measurements of Snowfall...
  88. Suppression of Rain and Snow by Urban and Industrial Air Pollution
  89. Ten-Year Non-Randomized Cloud Seeding Program on the King's River
  90. Texas Drought, 2011
  91. Texas House of Representatives Request for Attorney General's Opinion
  92. Unilateral Geoengineering
  93. US Bureau of Reclamation Weather Damage Modification Program
  94. US Geological Survey: Water Data for the US
  95. US Library of Congress
  96. US National Climate Program, 2012
  97. US Senate Bill S.2192 (2007)
  98. US Senate, Global Climate Change Hearings, 1997
  99. US Senate, Projected and Past Effects of Climate Change
  100. Water Supply Enhancement, County of Santa Barbara
  101. Weather Modification- A Scenario for the Future
  102. Weather Enhancement Technologies International
  103. Weather Mitigation Research and Development Policy Authorization Act of 2007
  104. Weather Modification: Finding Common Ground
  105. Weather Modification for Precipitation Augmentation and its Potential Usefulness...
  106. Weather Modification, Inc.
  107. Weather Modification papers Published prior to 1969
  108. Weather Modification Permit Program, Colorado
  109. A Weather Situation with Strong Convection in the Middle Stratosphere
  110. What about weather modification?
  111. What You Should Know about Aircraft Engine Lubrication
  112. World lacks enough food, fuel as population soars
  113. Wolchover, Natalie, What Are Climate Change Skeptics Still Skeptical About?
  114. Venezuela turns to cloud-seeding to battle drought
  115. Zurgena anti-cloud seeding organisation keeps growing